I wrote a long-ass response to a rando youtube commenter today, then decided it was pointless to press enter there. I’m pressing enter here instead! You’re welcome!
Disclaimer: All of it’s about the US healthcare system from the perspective of somebody who fits under the umbrellas of several marginalised categories.
All your arguments so far suggest that you’ve not required any kind of ongoing care within our healthcare system, or you otherwise vicariously found out what that experience can be like. If your experience with long-term care is an outlier on the good side of that curve, congrats.
Good Insurance and Good Healthcare aren’t available to all citizens for a variety of reasons. Our medical care system historically has a problem with providing care1 and insurance for certain demographics. These groups include women, people of colour, trans/NB/gender non-conforming people, various disableds/chronic illness havers, indigenous people, lesbians, poor people, immigrants, unmarrieds, gays, child-free people, veterans, and other marginalised groups.
These are failings on the part of healthcare-professional schooling and training; healthcare administrators; healthcare workers who can’t overcome their biases and prejudices in order to treat patients; relevant companies like pharmaceuticals, insurance, medical supplies, long term care, etc; lobbyists; all our politicians, and other involved people and roles I don’t even know about. It’s not a moral failing nor the fault of the people to not have access to either insurance or healthcare, though many people intentionally voted for politicians who said they think those circumstances are desirable.
We’ve had a “wait til it’s an emergency” system for decades, which got worse with Covid. Major medical systems generally want doctors and other people with similar decision-making capabilities to see as many patients per day as possible. Many patients with complex health problems have to demand care over and over and over again, some at dozens of doctors. It takes months to get an appointment with a specialist, and that’s just for a consult. They might not even be capable of helping. If specialists can’t/won’t help, it’s up to primary care/family doctors to sort out. Suck it general practitioners!
Comparing and contrasting data trends; comparing and contrasting theories about how healthcare systems are supposed to work domestically and internationally; and comparing and contrasting the implementation of theories all are pointless if any of the discrepancies don’t get sorted, and the actual patients involved don’t get care they need. Policy holes that only affect some people are still failures.
This is why regulation is necessary. The point of it is to fix the parts of the theories and models that don’t work after application. They will all fail in some ways because they’re implemented by people. People are biased. People make mistakes. People can’t own up to and apologise for those biases and mistakes. People repeat their mistakes over and over again, refuse to grow, and some eventually stop apologising.
Ignoring that there’s inherent problems with the language of many healthcare-related laws and policies, and that they’re frequently poorly implemented at many levels, doesn’t make the problems go away. Faulting people for having health problems, for having problems with bad policies that sometimes target them, doesn’t make the problems or the people go away. Some of those people will die, but there’s always gonna be more people and more problems, barring a cataclysmic human extinction event. Or an alien takeover. Or a revolution staged by our robot overlords.
Your comments about the Affordable Care Act, left-wingers, and right-wingers serve…what purpose? Conservatives in the 70s did help create some version of a plan for a better healthcare system. However, when actual implementation of similar philosophies became reality under President Obama about 50 years later, it was conservative politicians holding up the process until they got what they wanted: less regulation. People who pushed for that don’t really seem to understand, or care, or both, that that translates into poorer healthcare outcomes for everybody, not just for the demographics they don’t appreciate.
Politicians have allowed themselves good and tax-funded healthcare, though, so that’s cool for them. Ever since some of those same politicians in the 60s recognised that more people will need their healthcare paid for, the national conversation about it has been decades of complaining and stalling so they, lobbyists, insurance underwriters, and other babies who refuse to be kicked off the taxpayer teat oligarchs can get richer.
This is unsustainable. Unfortunately, many of us have been convinced that the real health2 of our entire population matters less than a few dozen or so people getting stupid rich. It matters less than politicians, popular political commentators, and others who think they have standing being able to yell and cry about how some people don’t deserve healthcare. These observations are based on my own consideration of the history of behavioural patterns in people of middle North America.
I don’t fucking know what the solutions are, and nobody’s asking me. But, perhaps we could start with giving trans people the healthcare they need. Yuh know. We could all put our differences behind us. For science. You monster.
1 Care: Ethical research, ethical education, and desired and measurable treatment outcomes.
2 Real health: Health that’s measurable, either by test or by self-report. Has nothing to do with normative healthcare ideals based on bad science, eg skinny is good and fat is bad.




